When plotting your retirement strategy, the main aim is to establish a consistent and dependable source of income that will last throughout your life. Annuities can be an effective tool for this purpose. dividend stocks There are two typical methods to accomplish this. Certain individuals nearing retirement prefer ensuring their financial stability and having a secure income stream through an annuity While some look for growth and adaptability through dividend stocks.
Grasping how these investment options function and evaluating their associated risks, expenses, and tax impacts can assist you in choosing which one aligns most effectively with your retirement strategy.
Here’s all the information you require.
How dividend stocks and annuities create retirement income
A significant number of corporations, particularly those with considerable tenure, allocate part of their earnings to shareholders as dividends. Individuals who have retired and possess these types of equities for an extended period can reap a consistent flow of revenue without needing to liquidate assets, all while potentially capitalizing on rises in share values down the line. Such growth in asset value aids in surpassing inflation rates over the course of one’s original stake.
Robust dividend-paying firms often boost their distributions annually. In the long term, this approach can be quite advantageous. reinvesting dividends Can enhance returns further, making this choice suitable if you're looking for both income and growth. Typically, most dividend-paying stocks offer income on a quarterly basis, but some pay out monthly .
On the contrary, annuities are agreements with life insurance firms that ensure a specific amount of regular income. These financial products provide a consistent payment stream and safeguard against longevity risk or the chance of exhausting your savings.
Annuities produce income via fixed interest rates or the increase from their underlying investments. Fixed annuities offer predictable payouts, while variable annuities And with index-linked annuities, their value changes according to the stock market’s performance. What makes annuities attractive is the assurance provided by the insurance company—regardless of your lifespan, you will continue to receive consistent payments.
Dividend-paying stocks versus annuities: A comparison
Payout annuities and dividend stocks each have distinct risks and trade-offs that require thorough consideration prior to determining which option best suits your needs.
-
Risks
Similar to all investments, both dividend stocks and annuities come with their own set of risks.
One major advantage of annuities is their capacity to efficiently shift the risk of exhausting your retirement funds or experiencing declines due to market fluctuations onto an insurance provider. Regardless of whether you reach age 100 or face a downturn in the financial markets, your payments continue uninterrupted according to the conditions outlined in your agreement. For those wary of taking risks, this feature offers significant peace of mind.
Nonetheless, it's crucial to keep in mind that the security offered by an annuity relies solely on the financial health of the insurance provider, and variable annuities may lose their worth should the markets experience a slump.
While dividend stocks typically exhibit lower volatility compared to growth stocks, they still come with their own set of risks. The prices can vary, and you might experience potential short-term declines.
Here’s an additional significant point to take into account: Should a corporation lack the financial means to continue distributing dividends, these payments may be reduced. Such a move could lead to a sharp decline in share value. For instance, Walgreens previously stood as a cornerstone of many portfolios. Dividend Aristocrats Here’s a list of companies that have consistently issued dividends for at least 25 consecutive years. Nevertheless, once the firm decided to discontinue its dividend payments in January 2025, the stock price—which had been struggling—plummeted below $10 per share.
To reduce this risk and to streamline stock picking, numerous investors choose to dividend mutual funds or dividend ETFs .
-
Complexity
Annuities are notorious for being complex. The contracts can run into dozens of pages, typically filled with technical terms, limitations, and perplexing fee systems. Despite this, optional riders could include features similar to insurance, like adjustments for inflation or death benefits These additional perks come with higher expenses.
Dividend stocks, however, are quite simple. By buying shares in companies that distribute dividends or investing in a dividend-focused exchange-traded fund (ETF), you earn regular payments. That's all there is to it. Although choosing the appropriate stocks does demand some investigation and ongoing attention, the entire investment procedure tends to be clearer and simpler compared to other types of investments. buying an annuity .
-
Fees and cost
Annuities often involve substantial fees, which can considerably affect your total earnings. The specific fees vary based on the kind of annuity selected; they may encompass administration expenses, death and expense fees, investment management charges, as well as penalties for withdrawing funds prematurely. Notably, variable annuities are particularly known for their hefty fees. high fees and commissions .
However, certain annuities — like single-premium immediate annuities (SPIAs) — offer a more straightforward and budget-friendly choice. Payments begin within one year, however, there’s a caveat: To receive a substantial income during your retirement years, you must initially commit a considerable sum of money.
On the contrary, dividend stocks come with significantly lower expenses. Investors typically do not incur brokerage fees when purchasing and trading these stocks, largely due to the increase in readily accessible platforms. commission-free trading ETFs focusing on dividend-paying stocks provide an affordable means to invest in a well-diversified collection of equities that generate income.
When comparing costs and fees, dividend stocks clearly come out ahead as being more economical compared to annuities.
-
Liquidity
Aside from investing in real estate Annuities rank as some of the most illiquid investment options available. After you contribute to an annuity agreement, withdrawing your funds can often be challenging , if not impractical. Many annuities also come with surrender fees for early withdrawals, which can persist for multiple years. Additionally, attempting to access your funds before this period may result in penalties. qualified annuity Before reaching age 59½, you'll face a 10 percent tax penalty imposed by the IRS.
These limitations might present difficulties whether you're dealing with a significant cost or just wish to diversify your investment approach.
In the meantime, dividend stocks are very liquid since investors can readily convert their shares into cash through sales. Their flexibility makes them an attractive option for retirees who require prompt access to funds. Although selling may incur capital gains taxes, these stocks offer investment control that annuities simply cannot provide.
-
Taxes
A major distinction between annuities and dividend stocks lies in their tax treatment.
Dividend-paying stocks, especially those that distribute " qualified dividends (by meeting certain holding period requirements), they receive beneficial tax treatment. These dividends are subject to taxation at a reduced rate. long-term capital gains rates , typically below the rates for regular income.
This renders qualified dividend stocks a tax-effective method to create retirement income, particularly beneficial for investors in lower brackets. tax brackets .
One important consideration is that dividends earned in taxable brokerage accounts are taxed annually, so you will owe taxes on these passive income payments every year they are received. This is why many financial advisors suggest holding dividend stocks within a tax-advantaged retirement account, like a 401(k) or an IRA. Roth IRA .
Annuities provide tax-deferred growth, allowing your investments to increase without being taxed immediately. Nonetheless, when you start withdrawing funds from an annuity, the taxable part will be considered ordinary income. Consequently, this could lead to a larger tax liability because ordinary income tax rates tend to be higher compared to capital gains rates, particularly affecting retirees who fall into higher-income categories.
So while you may steer clear of taxes while your funds increase within an annuity Eventually, when you withdraw funds or begin receiving periodic payments from the insurance company, you will be taxed on all of the growth (and possibly part of the principal) at your usual income tax rate.
Weighing your options?
When seeking professional advice regarding your investment management or retirement planning, ’s AdvisorMatch I can link you with a Certified Financial Planner™ who will assist you in reaching your financial objectives.
Which performs better for retirement: annuities or dividend stocks?
There isn’t a universal solution when deciding between an annuity and dividend stocks for retirement. While evaluating your choices, keep these factors in mind:
Risk tolerance
- Annuities provide assured income, which makes them perfect for retirees seeking financial stability and safeguarding their investments from market fluctuations — even if it means foregoing potentially greater earnings.
- Stocks that pay dividends involve market risks, yet they offer higher growth prospects and the ability to surpass inflation rates.
Liquidity needs
- Annuities lack liquidity and come with penalties for premature withdrawals. Consequently, they offer significantly lower flexibility compared to most other investment options and financial tools.
- Dividend-paying stocks can be readily sold whenever needed, providing faster access to funds at a reduced expense when you require liquidity.
Income preferences
- Annuities offer a consistent stream of income throughout one’s lifetime. They are frequently likened to pensions or dubbed as "replacement paychecks" because of their regular payments.
- Stocks that pay dividends can create passive income yet they remain vulnerable to market ups and downs as well as possible reductions in payouts.
Tax considerations
- Annuities accumulate without taxes until withdrawal, but both premature withdrawals and some payout amounts are subject to taxation as regular income.
- Stocks that pay dividends, especially those offering qualified dividends, are subject to taxation at lower rates similar to capital gains taxes.
Deciding between an annuity and dividend stocks doesn't necessarily have to be a completely exclusive choice.
Certain retired individuals might discover that merging these two types of investments proves quite effective. For instance, one could use annuities to handle basic living costs, whereas putting money into dividend stocks could provide extra income along with potential growth. This approach aids in crafting a well-rounded retirement plan.
Bottom line
Annuities and dividend stocks both play roles in retirement strategies, yet cater to distinct requirements. Annuities provide assured income streams, whereas dividend stocks focus on expansion and accessibility. Use annuities when prioritizing safety, and opt for dividend stocks when you prefer adaptability.
In the end, the most suitable method relies on your particular monetary circumstances. risk tolerance And long-term objectives. To make an educated choice, think about seeking advice from a financial advisor .
