It's quite possible that Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders could drop to the New York Giants with the third pick in this month’s NFL draft, however, an increasing number of notable analysts believe the team might overlook him and go another direction instead.
On Tuesday, April 8, ESPN’s Mel Kiper Jr. predicted that Penn State linebacker Abdul Carter — who is regarded as one of the top prospects in the 2025 draft irrespective of position — might drop down to third overall pick for New York, suggesting that the Giants would choose him with this selection.
Kiper anticipates that Sanders will be selected by the New Orleans Saints at the ninth overall pick, and he believes that the Giants will address their quarterback needs again when they have the 34th selection, which falls early in the second round. According to Kiper’s prediction for day two, the Giants are set to choose QB Jalen Milroe from Alabama with that pick, noting that the team plans to meet him later this week.

Currently, there is some affection towards Milroe in NFL circles, and he might integrate nicely into the team in New York. Kiper wrote He would get the opportunity to study under Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston, enhancing his pre-snap reads and refining his precision between short and intermediate distances. Milroe excels at throwing long passes and has the ability to alter games with his running. In 2024, he scored 20 times through rushing.
Milroe accounted for 45 touchdown passes During his tenure at Alabama, along with 33 rushing touchdowns.
Related: Giants Called Ideal Location for Second-Round Quarterback